Liana Shanti Truths
Member of the Nine Families

Shabeen Yadav

Her adult daughter was speaking about family control. Then her mother tried to stop the programs she had chosen.

“Ms. Narang is an adult, entitled to make her own decisions, even if they go against her parents’ wishes.”Dr. Kaia Alline · letter addressed to Judge Susan Oki Mollway
Shabeen Yadav
Shabeen Yadav
Who is Shabeen Yadav?

Gaurishi Narang’s mother

Shabeen Yadav is a member of the Nine Families.

Dr. Kaia Alline’s letter identifies Shabeen Yadav as Gaurishi Narang’s mother. Gaurishi’s own posts describe her family relationships and her experience of Liana’s teachings. Kaia’s letter and Malana’s account describe what followed.

The record

Her daughter’s choices

  • Gaurishi described pressure to comply with her parents’ wishes. In a May 17, 2022 post, she wrote about difficulty making her own decisions, feeling obligated to be “the good kid,” and learning to find her voice.
  • She also described feeling more empowered. Her posts discuss Liana’s teachings, Father Wound, and her excitement about pursuing her own business plans.
  • Kaia says Shabeen asked her to stop sharing programs with Gaurishi. Kaia’s letter states that Gaurishi was an adult and that she later learned Gaurishi had been hospitalized at her parents’ request.
  • Malana describes Joe Scoppino and Steve Hassan’s involvement. In the supplied excerpt, Malana says Joe wrote a letter to help a family he did not know have their adult daughter involuntarily admitted to a mental facility, and that the parents worked with Hassan.
01 · Gaurishi’s own words

“I always did what they wanted me to”

On May 17, 2022, Gaurishi wrote about the pressure she felt to follow her parents’ wishes. She described their choices being imposed on her, difficulty making decisions as an adult, and keeping her head down after seeing her sister shouted at or hit.

“So I never learnt to find my voice”

Her post ends with a decision to uncover the trauma she described and stop allowing it to dictate her life.

May 17, 2022 · Gaurishi describes her relationship with her parents and the difficulty of finding her own voice.
May 17, 2022 · Gaurishi describes her relationship with her parents and the difficulty of finding her own voice.
02 · Her experience of the teachings

Empowerment, self-reflection, and her own plans

Gaurishi’s posts show how she described the teachings herself. She wrote about feeling empowered to express herself, reflected on withdrawing from people and becoming negative, and described a shift toward unconditional love and taking responsibility for her own choices.

She also shared excitement about pursuing her business plans and described Father Wound session 3 as “profound and powerful.”

May 15, 2022 · Excitement about pursuing her business plans.
May 15, 2022 · Excitement about pursuing her business plans.
May 17, 2022 · Reflection on distancing herself, negativity, and unconditional love.
May 17, 2022 · Reflection on distancing herself, negativity, and unconditional love.
May 22, 2022 · Feeling empowered to express her true self.
May 22, 2022 · Feeling empowered to express her true self.
June 10, 2022 · Her experience of Father Wound session 3.
June 10, 2022 · Her experience of Father Wound session 3.
03 · Selected excerpts from Kaia’s letter

Her mother asked Kaia to stop sharing information

Dr. Kaia Alline’s letter describes Gaurishi choosing two of her group programs and downloading free resources. Kaia says Gaurishi occasionally sent questions, then stopped participating. These are selected excerpts from the letter addressed to Judge Susan Oki Mollway.

“Soon after, I received a message on Instagram from Ms. Narang’s mother begging me to stop selling my programs to her daughter or sharing any information with her.”

“I did not respond. Ms. Narang is an adult, entitled to make her own decisions, even if they go against her parents’ wishes.”

“Still, I hold that I did not encourage or force Ms. Narang to visit my site, download information, or make purchases. From then on, I did not contact Ms. Narang’s mother, Shabeen Yadav.”

Kaia then describes learning that Shabeen was speaking against Liana and alleging that her programs had harmed Gaurishi. Kaia offers her own assessment of that behavior:

“Ms. Yadav shows a pattern of behavior to maintain or hold control over her daughter.”

“This type of parenting is of concern, as Ms. Narang is an adult. It is also authoritarian, dependent, and fits the mental/psychological abuse definition. I’ve since learned Ms. Narang has been hospitalized per her parent’s request.”

“I ask the court who is doing harm. The parents who took their daughter’s right to choose away, or the teacher who teaches sovereignty daily.”

Source: Dr. Kaia Alline, MA, EdD · supplied letter addressed to Judge Susan Oki Mollway. The supplied copy has blank signature and date lines.

04 · Malana’s account

A letter from Joe Scoppino.
Parents working with Steve Hassan.

In the supplied excerpt, Malana describes learning in the summer of 2023 about Joe Scoppino’s involvement. The following passages present her account:

“Fast forward to the summer of 2023, and I learned that Joe Scoppino even went as far as to write a letter to help a family HE DID NOT KNOW to get their young adult daughter – an intelligent college graduate, acquaintance of mine, and fellow student of Liana Shanti’s – INVOLUNTARILY admitted to a MENTAL FACILITY.”

“Her name is Gaurishi Narang.”

“And her parents did this because they felt threatened by her disclosures of ABUSE and her desire to implement Liana’s teachings and programs.”

“To make matters even more horrifying, Gaurishi’s parents actually worked with ‘cult expert’ Steve Hassan to get her admitted– a man who has a history of working as a VIOLENT ‘deprogammer’ in order to help families get their ADULT children to renounce their religious beliefs.”

Source: Malana’s account · excerpt supplied for this page.

After the involuntary admission, contact with the community stopped

According to community members, Gaurishi’s contact with Liana and the community was cut off after the involuntary admission. Community members describe her parents cutting off her access to that support.

The number of hospital admissions and whether Gaurishi was forced to take medication remain unclear in the available record. Her May 2022 post below describes a prescription and her own experience with antidepressants.

05 · A hospital admission in her own words

Gaurishi’s May 24, 2022 post

“About a week ago, I started taking antidepressants (after a lot of inquiry and checking as I didn’t want to take them). I was prescribed by a doctor here in a hospital that I was admitted in for some time.”

Gaurishi explicitly says she did not want to take the antidepressants and connects the prescription to her hospital admission. Community members read this as raising concern that she felt pressured to take medication she did not want.

Gaurishi wrote that she had been admitted to a hospital for some time and had been prescribed antidepressants. She described her experience and asked the group for support.

This May 2022 post documents Gaurishi’s own account of a hospital admission. Malana describes learning in summer 2023 of an involuntary admission arranged by the parents. The material shown here does not establish whether these accounts concern the same admission or separate admissions.

May 24, 2022 · Gaurishi’s own account of a hospital admission and her request for support.
May 24, 2022 · Gaurishi’s own account of a hospital admission and her request for support.
Expanded screenshot